Fact or Fiction

Dispelling popular myths, misperceptions, and urban legends with logic (and humor)

Identifying misleading arguments and statistics and searching for pragmatic solutions

The place for critical thinkers, skeptics, and political centrists

Politics                                        Business
Issues                                              Taxes
Life                                              Research
Health                                         Questions
Entertainment                               The Truth
Media                                The Whole Story

Deer Crossings and Driver Safety

Print the article

This entry was posted on 10/27/2008 4:24 PM and is filed under Life, Travel.

To the Editor “From Kearneysville:

“I live near a deer crossing and they keep getting hit.  The county should move the deer crossing sign somewhere else.  It is too dangerous for the deer to cross where it is now.”

This is a real letter that Jay Leno read during “Headlines” on his September 22 show.  We laugh, but maybe this person is onto something.

Last week, I wrote about deer whistles and promised some ideas for making the roads safer.  A recent U.S. Department of Transportation PowerPoint presentation lists a bunch of strategies for avoiding collisions with deer.  (By the way, deer whistles top the list of ineffective strategies.)

Exactly what is effective?  You guessed it: moving deer crossings.  One of the best mitigation strategies is simply to install fencing along the road.  A more complete strategy involves combining some form of separate overpass or underpass for wildlife with the fencing.  Deer need to migrate and move about; these methods channel them to safer places for crossing roads.

The report also suggests creating some form of sensor for roadways that is capable of detecting the presence of large animals or obstructions.  In the future, deer might be scared off somehow, or even better, drivers could be alerted electronically or through sound to obstructions in the road.  It might work sort of like a deer whistle for drivers, except that it will actually work.

Until then, the best strategies will remain driving slowly and being extra vigilant around areas where deer tend to cross the road.
 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
Trackback specific URL for this entry
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments

    • 11/5/2008 4:05 PM Dennis McCargar wrote:
      I kept readin g the article on deer crossings, hoping to find the trick we always used in Colorado, when I was a lad...too many years ago. Deer will,
      invariably look towards your headlights
      much the same as a person would when
      suddenly met in the dark. The thing is
      deer eyes show up red at night, in your headlights, so, we just drove no more than the speed limit--a good practice, especially at night, and watched the side of the road for those tell-tale red pinpoints--deer eyes.
      Reply to this
    • 8/10/2010 10:35 AM Cam wrote:
      "The report also suggests creating some form of sensor for roadways that is capable of detecting the presence of large animals or obstructions."

      They already use such a thing in Colorado! I saw it on Hwy 160 from Durango to Pagosa Springs. They have sensors somewhere off in the woods, near the highway, and when a large animal triggers one of the sensors, the highway sign lights up and flashes, warning drivers that deer are near the highway. I thought what an awesome idea! I hope it really works!
      Reply to this
    • 10/28/2010 12:25 PM Jack Wilborn wrote:
      That is exactly what they did here on Highway 93 North out of Missoula. We used to see many deer nailed by the side of the road and many people hurt or killed by hitting them. I would first like to point out we could probably drop the killing rate by drivers slowing during dawn and dusk when these animals are really moving from feeding to sleeping grounds (or vise-verse) and watching for them. We actually stopped on Highway 90 east to let a group of deer cross, many people passed us at 70+ MPH, even though we had STOPPED in the right lane.

      When they refurbished Highway 93 North, they included fencing and a LARGE crossing bridge complete with grass and fencing along it's side. This year I've seen one dead animal in this area.

      California knew this when they created some of the freeways of the 70's where they made under freeway passes for the critters and found the animals diverted from normal paths to go UNDER a freeway. I have also witnessed deer go under Highway 93 where they have some very large stream pipes under the road... These animals seem to understand what's happening, at least I'm hoping that's the case.

      Also, sometimes they just launch out of the trees next to the road and you hit them, such is fate, so not all are to blame. But during dusk and dawn keep your speed down, your eyes open for any movement at the edge of the clearing for the road, you might be surprised at the animals you are able to save and maybe your or your family.
      Reply to this
    Leave a comment

    Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

     Enter the above security code (required)

     Name (required)

     Email (will not be published) (required)

     Website

    Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.